The Absolute Best Pizza in Jeffersonville [Updated 2026]

Trust me when I say that I've tasted some unforgettable slices in Jeffersonville, and I’ve meticulously reviewed 12 of the top spots that are dishing out mouthwatering pies. With a keen eye for flavor, crust perfection, and that magical cheese pull, I’ve navigated everything from family-owned treasures to trendy pizzerias, all in the name of finding the ultimate pizza experience.

Why should you take my word for it? Well, let’s just say I’ve made it my mission to leave no crust unturned, and my taste buds are practically seasoned experts by now. Whether you’re a die-hard pepperoni fan or a lover of gourmet toppings, I’ve got the scoop on where to satisfy your pizza cravings in this charming town. Let’s dive into the deliciousness!

A Pizza the Pie / The Spot on 10th

Highlights
Fresh and delicious pizza
Buttery, garlicky crust
Great value for money
Excellent service
Generous slice sizes

Nestled in the heart of Jeffersonville, A Pizza the Pie / The Spot on 10th has quickly asserted itself as a beloved gem for pizza lovers like myself. Upon entering, I was immediately greeted by the tantalizing aroma of dough baking, which set the stage for what was to come. The buttery, garlicky crust stole the show! Each bite was a delightful mix of crispy and chewy—an alchemy that only happens with fresh ingredients and expert hands.

What impressed me most was the generous slice sizes; it's hard not to feel satisfied after digging into their mouthwatering offerings. The toppings were not only abundant but also truly delicious, enhancing the overall experience without overwhelming my palate.

Additionally, the service here is commendable. The staff greeted me with a warm smile and were eager to recommend their favorite menu items. It made the atmosphere feel both friendly and welcoming, which is often hard to come by.

In terms of value for money, I was pleasantly surprised—it's rare to find such quality pizza without breaking the bank. Overall, A Pizza the Pie / The Spot on 10th has undoubtedly earned a spot in my heart, and I can confidently say it's a must-try for anyone in Jeffersonville!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Louisville.

Greenside Pizzeria

Highlights
New York style pizza
Above average salads
Excellent drinks
Great staff friendliness
Cozy seating atmosphere

Greenside Pizzeria in Jeffersonville has quickly risen to the top of my pizza ranking, and it's easy to see why. As soon as I stepped inside, I was enveloped by a cozy atmosphere that made me feel instantly at home. The friendly staff greeted me with warm smiles, setting the tone for a delightful dining experience.

Now, let’s talk pizza! Their New York style pizza truly embodies the classic charm of the Big Apple. The crust is perfectly thin and crispy, providing just the right amount of chew—it's a slice of heaven! The toppings are generously applied, ensuring that each bite is a flavor explosion.

To complement my meal, I also indulged in one of their above-average salads. It was refreshingly crisp and added a nice balance to my pizza feast. And let’s not forget the excellent drinks on offer—perfect for washing down those gooey, cheesy slices!

Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Greenside Pizzeria deserves a spot on your must-visit list. With such a delightful combination of delicious food and a welcoming atmosphere, it's a pizza lover's paradise!

You might also want to check out the best wings in Lexington.

Geraldine's Kitchen

Highlights
Amazing local spot
Friendly, prompt service
Hot and fresh food
Customizable menu options
Charming diner atmosphere

At Geraldine's Kitchen, I was greeted by a delightful atmosphere that immediately made me feel at home. This charming local spot is a hidden gem, perfect for pizza lovers seeking both quality and comfort. Right from the start, the friendly and prompt service set the stage for what would become a truly enjoyable meal.

As I perused the menu, I was thrilled to find a variety of customizable options that catered to every palate. I decided to create my own masterpiece, topping my pizza with a bold blend of vibrant veggies and savory meats. When it arrived, it was hot and fresh, with the perfect balance of crispy crust and melty cheese that you simply crave. Each bite was a joyous celebration of flavors that danced on my tongue.

It's clear that Geraldine's Kitchen isn’t just about good pizza; it’s a place where the love for food shines through every detail. If you’re in Jeffersonville looking for a delightful pizza experience, this lively diner should be at the top of your list. I guarantee you’ll leave with a full belly and a big smile! 🍕

You might also want to check out the best goodwill in Lexington.

Arni's New Albany

Highlights
Great food every visit
Friendly cook service
Delay during busy hours
Small parking lot
Nostalgic dining experience

Review of Arni's New Albany

Stepping into Arni's New Albany in Jeffersonville feels like a delightful journey back in time. The nostalgic dining experience it offers is just as comforting as the pizzas they serve. On my latest visit, I was immediately greeted by the friendly cook service, who treated every dish they created like a masterpiece.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza itself! Each bite was an explosion of flavor, leaving me craving more. Notably, the consistently great food makes Arni's a reliable spot for pizza lovers. However, be prepared for a short wait during busy hours; the exquisite flavors are worth the delay!

The only downside during my visit was the small parking lot, which can become a bit of a puzzle when everyone has the same idea on a Friday night. Despite that minor frustration, the warm ambiance and delicious pies make it easy to forgive.

In conclusion, if you're searching for the best pizza in Jeffersonville, Arni's New Albany should definitely be on your radar. It's an experience that combines great food with a welcoming atmosphere — a true gem worth revisiting!

You might also want to check out the best tattoo shops in Louisville.

Mimo's Pizzeria

Highlights
Charming and cozy atmosphere
Ideal for romantic dates
Friendly but inconsistent service
Prices a bit on the high side
Mixed reviews on food quality

Mimo's Pizzeria in Jeffersonville is a delightful little spot that strikes a perfect balance between charm and cheekiness. The moment you step inside, you’re greeted by a cozy atmosphere that feels almost like a hug from an old friend. It’s an ideal hideaway for a romantic date or a casual night out with friends.

However, let’s chat about the pizza, which is naturally the star of the show. I found the pies to be a mixed bag; the flavors intrigued my palate, but some of the dishes left me longing for that extra oomph. While the prices are a touch on the higher side, you’re undeniably paying for an experience rather than just food.

Service was friendly, yet it had moments of inconsistency that left me scratching my head. One server seemed genuinely invested, while another felt as if they were just clocking in for a shift. Despite the ups and downs, Mimo’s has a certain appeal that keeps you coming back for more. So if you’re in Jeffersonville and in the mood for pizza with a side of charm, Mimo's Pizzeria is definitely worth a visit—just go in with a flexible appetite and an open mind!

You might also want to check out the best mall in Louisville.

Cast Iron Steak House

Highlights
Great service from staff
Unique ribeye with boursin
Delicious mac and cheese
Quick dining experience
Variety of appetizer options

Having heard whispers of great pizza amid the steak-centric menu, I ventured into Cast Iron Steak House in Jeffersonville, eager for a taste of their culinary magic. The moment I entered, I was greeted by the exceptional service of their friendly staff, setting the stage for what I hoped would be a delightful meal.

While the restaurant is primarily known for its steaks, I couldn't resist sampling their pizza. I was pleasantly surprised to find that it had a unique ribeye topping infused with creamy boursin. The combination of flavors danced on my palate, making it a must-try for adventurous eaters. The presentation of the pizza was equally impressive, with a perfectly crisp crust that balanced the richness of the toppings.

Furthermore, the delightful side of mac and cheese added a comforting touch to the meal, pairing wonderfully with the pizza. The hustle and bustle of the restaurant allowed for a quick dining experience, perfect for those on the go.

In a place where steak reigns supreme, Cast Iron Steak House proves that pizza can hold its own. If you're looking for a playful twist on traditional flavors, this spot deserves a place on your pizza radar!

You might also want to check out the best hibachi in Lexington.

Falls City Beer Event Space

Highlights
Pizza Bombs Delight
Great atmosphere
Competitive pricing
Calzone is a must-try
Clean and tidy restrooms

As I stepped into the Falls City Beer Event Space, I was immediately drawn in by its vibrant atmosphere. It’s a place that exudes an inviting charm, making it an ideal spot for pizza lovers and beer enthusiasts alike. I couldn’t resist trying their Pizza Bombs, and let me tell you, they were an explosion of flavor in every bite! The crispy crust gave way to a cheesy, savory filling that left me craving more.

Beyond the delightful pizza options, the calzone is a must-try. It’s generously stuffed, perfectly balanced, and it's evident that quality ingredients are a top priority here. The prices are surprisingly competitive, which is a refreshing bonus in today's world of gourmet pizza shops.

I was also pleased to find the restrooms clean and tidy, a detail not often noted but certainly appreciated. Whether you're grabbing a slice after a night out or settling in for a cozy meal with friends, Falls City manages to combine indulgence and comfort seamlessly. In my quest for the best pizza in Jeffersonville, I can confidently say that this spot deserves a place on your must-visit list!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Columbus.

Mac's @ Mile Wide

Highlights
Best pizza in Louisville
Outstanding customer service
Enjoyable brewery atmosphere
Unique and classic menu options
Fantastic quality brick oven pizza

Mac's @ Mile Wide has quickly established itself as a top contender for the best pizza in Jeffersonville. As soon as I walked in, I was greeted by the friendly staff, whose exceptional customer service immediately put me at ease. The lively brewery atmosphere added to the overall experience, creating a welcoming vibe perfect for gathering with friends.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show—the pizza. Mac's offers a delightful array of both unique and classic menu options that cater to every palate. I opted for their brick oven pizza, and I was blown away by the flavors. The crust was perfectly crispy, providing a delightful base for top-quality ingredients that sang on my taste buds.

Each slice was an experience in itself, with a harmonious blend of toppings that balanced creativity and tradition. Whether you're in the mood for something adventurous or a classic pepperoni, Mac's delivers on all fronts. For anyone seeking an exceptional pizza in Jeffersonville, I highly recommend Mac's @ Mile Wide. It’s a must-visit for pizza lovers that guarantees a fantastic culinary experience!

You might also want to check out the best salads in Louisville.

PARLOUR Pizza + Pints

Highlights
Lively and casual atmosphere
Delicious smoked wings
Hearty specialty pizzas
Attentive and friendly service
Reasonable pricing

PARLOUR Pizza + Pints immediately draws you in with its lively and casual atmosphere, perfect for a night out or a laid-back lunch. As I settled in, I noticed patrons enjoying not only the pizza but also the delicious smoked wings. I couldn't resist trying them, and let me tell you—dipping those tender wings into the house-made sauce was a revelation!

As for the pizza, their specialty offerings are truly a feast for the senses. I opted for the "PARLOUR Supreme," loaded with fresh toppings that danced across my palate with every bite. The crust was perfectly crispy, striking that ideal balance between chewy and crunchy—a hallmark of a great pizza.

The service here deserves a nod too; the staff was attentive and friendly, genuinely making me feel at home. And let’s not forget the best part—everything is reasonably priced, which is a significant plus in today’s dining scene.

Overall, my visit to PARLOUR was a delightful culinary journey. If you're in Jeffersonville and searching for a slice of pizza heaven, look no further. PARLOUR is surely a must-visit for both pizza aficionados and casual diners alike!

You might also want to check out the best thrift stores in Louisville.

BoomBozz Pizza & Watch Bar

Highlights
Exceptional service by Koa
Great outdoor dining experience
Delicious All Meat Classic pizza
Friendly and pleasant staff
Tasty soft pretzels available

Stepping into BoomBozz Pizza & Watch Bar felt like uncovering a treasure trove of flavor right in the heart of Jeffersonville. The first thing that struck me was the exceptional service provided by Koa, whose enthusiasm matched that of a chef presenting a masterpiece.

The atmosphere was vibrant, complemented by a great outdoor dining experience that beckoned me to sit back and unwind. Eager to dive into the menu, I opted for the All Meat Classic pizza, a decision that made my taste buds sing. Each bite delivered a delightful combination of flavors, from savory pepperoni to succulent sausage, all harmonizing beautifully.

In addition to the main event, I couldn't resist trying their tasty soft pretzels, which paired well with the lively ambiance. I also appreciated the friendly and pleasant staff, making every moment feel more like a visit to a friend’s house than a restaurant.

Overall, my experience at BoomBozz was a celebration of culinary spontaneity with just the right touch of warmth. If you're on the hunt for pizza that's both delicious and served with a smile, look no further than this Jeffersonville gem!

You might also want to check out the best lawyer in Lexington.

Derby City Pizza

Highlights
Phenomenal service
Fun family atmosphere
Delicious Chicken Bacon Ranch
Themed nights like karaoke
Clean and welcoming space

Review of Derby City Pizza

I recently had the pleasure of visiting Derby City Pizza in Jeffersonville, and let me tell you, it was a delightful experience from start to finish. As soon as I stepped in, the fun family atmosphere welcomed me with open arms. The vibrant decorations and friendly staff made it feel like a home away from home.

What truly stole the show, though, was their Chicken Bacon Ranch pizza. Imagine biting into a perfect crust topped with creamy ranch dressing, succulent chicken, and crispy bacon—it was a party in my mouth! Each slice was an adventure that kept me coming back for more. And if you're someone who thrives on excitement, you’ll love their themed nights; I was fortunate enough to catch one of their karaoke nights, adding an extra layer of fun to the evening.

The cleanliness of the establishment further impressed me; it radiated a sense of care and attention that's sometimes lost in casual dining. With fantastic service and mouthwatering pies, it's clear that Derby City Pizza stands out in the vibrant Jeffersonville pizza scene. Whether you're with family or friends, this is a place you won't want to miss.

You might also want to check out the best divorce lawyers in Lexington.

Pearl Street Taphouse

Highlights
Homey and welcoming atmosphere
Quick and friendly service
Delicious pretzel appetizer
Excellent beer cheese burger
Clean and well-maintained restrooms

Pearl Street Taphouse has a homey and welcoming atmosphere that immediately makes you feel at ease. As I settled in, the friendly service was like a warm hug—quick and attentive, they truly made me feel at home. I kicked off my visit with their delightful pretzel appetizer, which was a perfect pair to the upcoming pizza feast.

Now, let’s get to the star of the show: the pizza! Their selection boasts an impressive variety, but I opted for their signature pie. The crust was thin and perfectly crisp, topped generously with fresh ingredients that exploded with flavor in every bite. The balance of cheese and toppings was outstanding, leaving me craving just one more slice.

After indulging in the pizza, I couldn’t resist trying their beer cheese burger, which was just as delicious. The clean and well-maintained restrooms added to the overall pleasant experience, reflecting the establishment’s commitment to quality.

In short, Pearl Street Taphouse offers not just pizza but a joyful dining experience. If you’re in Jeffersonville, be sure to stop by; it just might become your new favorite spot!

You might also want to check out the best shopping malls in Louisville.